W2 Issues/Concerns

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


Check out our weekly blog posts and see the latest news and discussions happening in the HR world of business.

Are You Responsible if Employees Fail to Report Hours Worked?

If you typically have your employees take charge of recording and/or verifying their own hours, then you’ll want to pay attention to the outcomes of a recent lawsuit that tackles the issue of whether employers are on the hook for unpaid wages if workers forget to accurately report their hours worked.


In the case in question, the pharmacy chain CVS was recently sued by two of its pharmacy technicians (PTs) amid claims that the store failed to pay them for time spend using LEARNet, an online training tool the PTs are required to use to complete periodic, mandatory training module. Because the LEARNet program doesn’t record how long an employee takes to complete the training, the pharmacy chain requires that the PTs report the hours spent on the program outside of the store to their lead PT, who is in turn responding for documenting the time and notifying the store manager or shift supervisor to enter the hours into the payroll system.


Per the case, the evidence showed that the lead PT never verified whether the PTs were paid for the training. Further, the store manager – who was ultimately responsible for compensation – was aware that the PTs had completed their training outside of a regular work shift but deemed the work non-compensable because it constituted “continuing education.”


CVS was ultimately held liable for the unpaid work, even though it had written policies in place that prohibited work from being completed outside of a regular work shift and required all PTs to record and report all hours worked, as well as review and sign their time cards to verify that they had been paid for all hours worked.  In the decision – which took place in Massachusetts – the court cited a state law suggesting that it is the employers responsibility to maintain time records for employees. The court then turned to a Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court decision that governs the recovery of unpaid wages when the employer’s records are inaccurate or inadequate and awarded the two employees triple damages under the state’s Wage Act, as well as statutory interest and lawyers’ fees.


So, what’s the take home message here? Ultimately, CVS had the right policies in place and had done well to have them written down, but sadly the policies attempted to shift at least some of the burden of ensuring adequate hourly work reporting to the employees themselves. Employers should certainly follow this lead, but must also at least try to be aware of when employees are working off the clock – such as responding to business emails late at night or working through a lunch hour – and ensure that they are compensated accordingly. If your workplace prohibits after hours work, be sure to inform the employee and follow disciplinary policies in accordance with those laid out in your employee handbook or other similar employee communication.


Abel can help with enacting time keeping best practices and payroll. To read more on the case – St. Pierre et al v. CVS Pharmacy – click here.

[pro_ad_display_adzone id="4020"]

Featured BLOGS

  • Should you opt for a PEO or a payroll company?

    Joe Frazier versus Muhammad Ali, Boston Red Sox versus New York Yankees. Green Bay Packers versus Chicago Bears. PEO versus payroll companies. Well, turns out one of these things are not like the other and not just because they don’t involve sports teams and packed stadiums, but rather because there really isn’t any rivalry, per se, between a PEO company and a payroll company. You see, while they both help you offload some of your HR responsibilities, they function in entirely different ways. A payroll company really dials in and takes over just one facet of the human resources world.

  • HR how-to: Do you have a gift giving policy?

    While you’re still nursing your turkey hangover, we’ve been busy thinking about the holiday season ahead and while it’s sure to be full of festive cheer, it’s also a season ripe for some rather large HR pitfalls. Take the good ol’ holiday gift. Whether it’s a secret Santa, a white elephant, a Yankee Swap, or any other name for a holiday exchange, it is one holiday tradition that definitely could be helped by the addition of a gift-giving policy. What are the rules? (of the gift giving, not the game, obviously!) Make it voluntary: The holiday period can be tough


FSA | Commuter New Employee Abel Portal Time Clock